Paul Klee (1879–1940) was a painter born in Switzerland who held German citizenship. A question he wrote in his diary in 1915 has the rhythm of a riddle. Its speaker has just been thinking about blood, war and death. In the last words of the question he gives himself an altogether different shape. For the space of a sentence, the name of a mineral becomes a name he can give himself.
Working with fragments
Can I, a crystal, die?
– Paul Klee, Tagebücher 1898–1918, 1915 · edition 1957, entry 951, p. 323.[1]
Klee arrives at this question by way of a field of wreckage. Familiar forms have come apart. He observes how hard it is to release one's hold on the pieces, and how those very pieces supply material for a painter. In a picture, two fragments may touch although the things to which they once belonged have long since separated. Klee imagines an impure crystal growing from such elements. A flawless jewel would leave out the part that matters to him here, the broken material out of which the new form takes shape.
Another name for the self
Towards the end of the entry Klee recalls the vulnerability of his own body. A person can bleed. A form that person discovers can outlast the moment of discovery, pass onto paper and come before another pair of eyes. The sudden leap from bodily memory to crystal allows both experiences to stand together. It gives a particular urgency to the painter's question about what it might mean for a form to survive.