Vedic poetry
Rigveda
Let these speak loudly forth; let us speak out aloud: to the loud speaking Pressing-stones address the speech; When, rich with Soma juice, Stones of the mountain, ye, united, swift to Indra bring the sound of praise.
Paul Valéry (1871–1945) was a French poet and essayist. He begins his meditation on a shell with three things one could put side by side on a table. A crystal, a flower and a shell have something in common for the eye, although each comes into being in its own way. Among irregular edges and accidental overlaps in our surroundings, the eye can readily follow their outlines. The harder work begins when we try to explain how those outlines arose.
[…] so a crystal, a flower, a shell stand out from the ordinary disorder of all the things we perceive.
– Paul Valéry, L’Homme et la coquille, 1937 · edition 1944, opening paragraph, p. 11.[1]
Consider what happens as you turn a crystal. The gleam goes off one face and appears on the next. The angle between them holds. Your eye grasps an order in that change without necessarily learning anything about the growth of the specimen. With the shell, to which Valéry gives his closest attention, the experience returns. A hand can trace a whorl with ease. Producing the same succession of whorls from a decision of one's own would be a very different undertaking.
The comparison brings out a familiar habit of looking. We tend to suppose that something easily recognized should also be easily explained. Each of these objects gives us reason to think again. And the shell adds a further complication. The animal forms its shelter in the course of living and grows along with it. A human maker wishing to reproduce it would have to work on material from outside and step back to judge the result. An attentive glance at a surface thus leads directly to the question of how a form comes about.