Ernst Bloch (1885–1977) was a German philosopher. In the first version of The Spirit of Utopia he asks what a Gothic building gives its visitors to see. Standing at the foot of a pier, one is conscious of the weight of the stone overhead. Yet the eye can follow the rising lines and receive the impression of a tree. High in the vault the ribs spread apart, and a cluster of leaves opens in the stone of a capital.
Following a line upwards
Here the stones blossom and bear fruit, the breath of life, long kept silent, reaches to the end and beyond.
– Ernst Bloch, Geist der Utopie, 1918, Die Erzeugung des Ornaments, p. 41.[1]
Such experiences give Bloch his unexpected verb. The stones bloom. The word “here” matters because it directs the eye to a particular way of building. A fruit carved in stone stays in its place. The eye, meanwhile, moves towards it and beyond it, picks out another figure and discovers an opening of coloured glass where a moment ago it expected a heavy wall. The carvers have given it both a reason to go on and a path it can take.
Where the wall opens
Bloch hears a breath that has long been silent. Someone standing at the pier might recognize something of their own intake of breath as they look up. The church gives a human impulse an outward form that many people can walk through. The fruit deserves a second glance in this reading. A flower opening in stone would already be a remarkable sight. The fruit adds the prospect of a development that is still to come when the first petal opens.