When the senator Nonius had to flee, he took only a ring from all his possessions. Set in it was an opal that Pliny the Elder valued at two million sesterces. According to Pliny, Mark Antony had its owner proscribed on account of the stone. Pliny marvelled as much at Antony’s greed as at the tenacity of Nonius, who refused to give up his ring.
Pliny the Elder (AD 23/24–79) devoted the thirty-seventh and final book of his Naturalis historia to gemstones. He described their colours and origins and how they were worked. He also wrote about collectors, imitations and precious rings. His account of the stones brought natural history together with life in the Roman world.
Where the stones and their stories came from
Pliny attached particular importance to where stones came from. He names places in India, Arabia and Egypt where they were found and distinguishes different varieties by their appearance and quality. These details also show how far Roman buyers looked beyond the borders of their empire.
He drew on earlier Greek and Roman authors. Theophrastus appears in the book on stones, as does the Roman scholar Varro. Pliny often records who had described a particular place of origin or a property of a stone. Alongside the stones themselves, the voices of his predecessors can still be heard in the text.
Pliny examines the stories
The so-called lynx stone shows how critically Pliny could approach such accounts. Earlier writers said that it formed from the urine of a lynx. Even Theophrastus had repeated accounts of the stone. Pliny considered the story false and doubted that anyone in his own time had ever seen such a stone. He also dismissed the healing properties attributed to it.
The book on stones as a historical source
The significance of this collection extends beyond Pliny’s own time. He preserved information from earlier writings that were subsequently lost, some of which are known only through his account. His book on stones thus gives us access to knowledge whose original sources are now missing.
The survival of this knowledge in turn owes much to the manuscript copies of the Naturalis historia. They transmitted the work throughout the Middle Ages. It was first printed in Venice in 1469 by Johannes of Speyer. Comparing the manuscripts remained important because errors and omissions had crept in during copying.
Today, Book 37 helps us understand where stones came from, how they were traded and how they were valued in antiquity. A study published in 2019 compared Pliny’s account with ten collection catalogues containing more than 4,000 gems and glass objects. What was recorded in writing can thus be tested against surviving objects.
The precise descriptions matter. Ancient stone names do not always denote the same mineral species as their modern counterparts. Colour, place of origin and other properties therefore need to be considered together to understand which stone Pliny meant.